Name: Thayer Jewelers
Address: 20 S. Palm Avenue, Sarasota, FL, 34236, US
Telephone: 941-955-8820
Price range: $$

EXPLORE NOW

About Us

Welcome to Thayer Jewelers, since 1982, Thayer Jewelers has sold only the finest heirloom quality jewelry, important colorless & natural fancy color diamonds, gem quality sapphires, rubies, emeralds and rare gemstones.

Thayer Jewelers

New Arrivals

Rolex Datejust 36mm #16030 ...

SKU: 8690

$5,800.00

| /

Stainless Steel Rolex #16030 Datejust 36mm with Silver Dial and Stick Indexes. Engine-Turned Bezel. Original Box & Papers, Just Serviced
6.61 Carat Colombian Emeral...

SKU: 3030

$34,500.00

| /

Platinum ring with one Gubelin certified 6.61 carat emerald and 4.71 carats of round brilliant diamonds. 18.66 grams
18k White Gold Natural Diam...

SKU: 8650

$75,000.00

| /

18k White gold necklace with 80 round brilliant diamonds weighing 41.74 carats and 1120 smaller round brilliant diamonds weighing 4.48 carats. 46.2...
View full details
14k White Gold Omega Necklace

SKU: 7658

$2,500.00

| /

14k White gold 4mm, 16" Omega Necklace 18.50 grams
Michael Sugarman Bracelet

SKU: 7565

$6,500.00

| /

Michael Sugarman 14k hand made bracelet. 50.14 grams
18k Emerald Earrings

SKU: 3110

$23,500.00

| /

18k White gold earrings with 8 cabochon emeralds weighing 18,75 carats and 22 round, pear shape and oval diamonds weighing 5.09 carats. 14.14 grams
18k Gold Hersheys Kisses Br...

SKU: 8615

$16,500.00

| /

18k Gold Hersheys Kisses Bracelet 92.05 grams. 7.5 in length. 0.75 in width. Yellow, white and rose gold accents.
Hammerman Brothers Necklace...

SKU: 7720

$47,000.00

| /

18k Hammerman Brothers Necklace & Earring Suite with 237 round brilliant diamonds weighing approximately 15.80 carats. 178 grams
14k White Gold Necklace

SKU: 8666

$3,500.00

| /

14k White Gold Necklace. 19.27 grams
14k Glass Bead Necklace

SKU: 8669

$1,200.00

| /

14k Glass Bead Necklace 25.95 grams
Tiffany & Co Sterling Silve...

SKU: 8671

$300.00

| /

Tiffany & Co Sterling Silver Earrings, 11.97g
Tiffany & Co. Paloma Picass...

SKU: 8670

$950.00

| /

Tiffany & Co. Paloma Picasso Sterling Silver Loving Hearts Bangle Cuff Bracelet, 45.34g
Lagos 18k Yellow Gold Ring ...

SKU: 8675

$7,500.00

| /

Lagos 18k yellow gold ring with square cut red rubies, round brilliant diamonds, and Mabe pearl. 18.96 grams size 6.5, Sizable
18K Earrings with Sapphires...

SKU: 0022

$3,400.00

| /

18K Earrings with 2 pink and 2 blue sapphires weighing 2.93 carats and 18 round brilliant diamonds weighing 0.27 carats 13.07 grams.
Italian Sterling Silver Nec...

SKU: 8672

$450.00

| /

Stunning Italian Sterling Silver Necklace, 56.82g
18k Turquoise, Ruby, Onyx &...

SKU: 8676

$3,800.00

| /

18k Turquoise, ruby, Onyx & Diamond Earrings, 19.42g
Watermelon Tourmaline Earrings

SKU: 8099

$1,000.00

| /

22k Watermelon Tourmaline earrings with 14k posts and friction backs. 3.84 grams
Piaget 18k Yellow Gold Watc...

SKU: 8677

$9,500.00

| /

Piaget 18k yellow gold. Manual movement. 24mm, Model #924A6. Lapis Lazuli dial in blue. Total weight 59.24g. Length 6.25in.
Platinum Earrings with Oval...

SKU: 8689

$3,450.00

| /

Platinum earrings featuring oval blue sapphires, 2.34 carats, and round white diamonds, 0.96 carats, 4.8 grams.
18k White Gold Diamond Pendant

SKU: 8681

$1,100.00

| /

18k White Gold Pendant. 1.75 grams. 0.45 carat round diamond, surrounded by 0.64 carats of round white diamonds
Rolex Lady-Datejust #79173 ...

SKU: 8684

$7,900.00

| /

Rolex Lady-Datejust #79173 Automatic movement. 26mm case. White dial. Diamond markers. 18k gold and stainless steel. Fluted bezel & Jubilee bra...
View full details
Rolex Datejust 26mm 18k Gol...

SKU: 8688

$9,850.00

| /

Stainless Steel & 18k Gold Rolex Datejust 26mm 179174 with salmon dial and diamond markers. Automatic movement, complete.
18k Pearl Brooch

SKU: 6502

$1,950.00

| /

18k Brooch with 12mm Saltwater Pearl and approximately 0.25 carats of diamonds. 11.82g
Omega Seamaster Aqua Terra ...

SKU: 8687

$21,000.00

| /

Brand New 18k Rose Gold Omega Seamaster Aqua Terra 150M Co-Axial GMT Chronograph 43mm on Red Gold on Alligator Strap with deployment Buckle. New R...
View full details
18k Gold & Stainless Steel ...

SKU: 8686

$15,800.00

| /

18k Gold & Stainless Steel Rolex GMT-Master II 40mm 116713 with black dial and two-tone bezel. Automatic movement, complete.

View All Products

Our Collections

View All Collections

Reviews

What a wonderful experience! We strolled into Thayer Jewelers looking for a vintage engagement ring and found a piece so amazing that I still can't believe it. They stayed open to show me the ring one last time as we were visiting from out of town.

- Julie Schneider

A wonderful place to shop! Jeremy is an expert gemologist and so attentive and accommodating. You can trust that he sells only the highest quality jewelry at fair prices. I have shopped elsewhere and can tell you that the service and quality here are unbeatable!

- Elizabeth Gavin

The owner Jeremy Thayer is deeply knowledgeable about jewelry, specially about rare gems. He has been for many year my go to guy for unique and rare gems. Check out his truly amazing jewelry pieces. You can trust him and his team. You will be in good hands.

- Rodrigo Wolf

Blog posts

August 12, 2023 Jeremy Thayer

How To Figure Out Your Partner's Ring Size Without Asking
The anticipation of popping the question or gifting a ring comes with its own set of challenges. One of the most daunting tasks can be determining your partner's ring size without raising any suspicion. While it might seem like a...
Read now
August 9, 2023 Jeremy Thayer

Engagement Ring Vs. Wedding Ring: What's The Difference?
Engagement and wedding ceremonies have long held prominent places in human cultures across the globe. Integral to these ceremonies are the symbols we cherish: the rings. However, there is a common dilemma for many - understanding the difference between an...
Read now
August 6, 2023 Jeremy Thayer

17 Engagement Ring Styles You Should Know
Choosing an engagement ring is a significant decision in anyone's life. It symbolizes love, commitment, and a future together. Given the importance, selecting a style that resonates with the wearer's personality and preference is crucial. While the market is brimming...
Read now

See more posts

About Us

New Arrivals

Rolex Datejust 36mm #16030 ...

6.61 Carat Colombian Emeral...

18k White Gold Natural Diam...

14k White Gold Omega Necklace

Michael Sugarman Bracelet

18k Emerald Earrings

18k Gold Hersheys Kisses Br...

Hammerman Brothers Necklace...

14k White Gold Necklace

14k Glass Bead Necklace

Tiffany & Co Sterling Silve...

Tiffany & Co. Paloma Picass...

Lagos 18k Yellow Gold Ring ...

18K Earrings with Sapphires...

Italian Sterling Silver Nec...

18k Turquoise, Ruby, Onyx &...

Watermelon Tourmaline Earrings

Piaget 18k Yellow Gold Watc...

Platinum Earrings with Oval...

18k White Gold Diamond Pendant

Rolex Lady-Datejust #79173 ...

Rolex Datejust 26mm 18k Gol...

18k Pearl Brooch

Omega Seamaster Aqua Terra ...

18k Gold & Stainless Steel ...

Our Collections

Reviews

Blog posts

How To Figure Out Your Partner's Ring Size Without Asking

Engagement Ring Vs. Wedding Ring: What's The Difference?

17 Engagement Ring Styles You Should Know

Come Vist Our Store

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Added to your cart: